November 19, 2026
In 2023, a family that had owned a 1925 cottage at 231 South Arlington Avenue for six decades sold it for $1 million. They had turned away developers for years. The architect Harold Zook designed the house, and it sits on a one-third-acre lot. According to The Real Deal, which credited Crain's with first reporting the listing, both houses beside it are replacement homes, and at least four nearby properties had sold to teardown buyers in the months before December 2025.
The new owner kept the chalet-style wood ceiling and the gingerbread staircase trim, added a mudroom and a basement powder room, and listed the house on December 18, 2025, at just under $1.5 million. Shaw Local reported that it sold on February 5, 2026, for $1.47 million, or $507 per square foot, for 2,906 square feet.
The Real Deal counted a sale on Illinois Street among the nearby teardown purchases. It closed in July 2025 for $1.7 million, and that price was for the land alone. A fully renovated historic house on one of the area's most desirable streets sold for less than a nearby lot with nothing on it.
Older houses in these blocks are not cheap houses that happen to be old. Their prices are set by the land under them, and that land is priced by what a builder can sell a new house on it for. If you're comparing Elmhurst with other western suburbs, that one fact changes how you read nearly every listing near downtown.
The City of Elmhurst's 2026 housing report counts 389 residential demolitions from 2020 through 2024. That works out to about 78 a year, or 3.1% of the city's estimated 12,639 single-family homes over those five years. The same report places demolitions and new home builds most often near the Prairie Path and City Centre, with more activity north of North Avenue and near Butterfield Road.
Those clusters sit close to the downtown restaurants and shops we covered in our look at downtown Elmhurst's dining turnover. A buyer who wants a modest older home within reach of City Centre is shopping the same houses that builders target.
The report treats this as a real constraint on the older stock. It describes homes from the mid-20th century as Elmhurst's moderately priced ownership housing, wanted by first-time buyers and by downsizers. It then notes that families planning to tear down and rebuild compete for those same older, smaller homes. Using Census estimates, it puts the median value of 1950s-built homes in Elmhurst at about $326,200 in the 2009–2013 period and $467,900 in the 2019–2023 period, a gain of 4.34% a year. Homes built in the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s rose more than 4% a year over the same span.
The builder's math works backward from the finished house. Shaw Local's transaction reports from this year show what new five-bedroom Elmhurst homes built in 2026 have closed for.
| Address | Closed | Price | Size | Per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 153 S. Kenmore Ave. | July 23, 2026 | $2.53 million | 5,867 sq ft | $430 |
| 444 E. Schiller St. | Oct. 9, 2026 | $1.6 million | 3,400 sq ft | $471 |
| 845 S. Colfax Ave. | Oct. 16, 2026 | $1.8 million | 3,332 sq ft | $540 |
Also on South Arlington, a house built in 2021 with 3,639 square feet on a 9,148-square-foot lot sold May 22, 2026, for $2.35 million.
Put the Zook cottage's $507 per square foot next to the table. A 1925 house, renovated and with its original details intact, sold within the per-square-foot range of brand-new construction in the same year. That only adds up if the land carries most of the value. A buyer near downtown is paying for the lot and the location. The house on top, old or new, changes the total less than most people expect.
Citywide, the numbers are just as steep. Patch reported in March 2026 that the average Elmhurst home sale price had reached $761,000, up from $410,000 five years earlier.
The same Patch story described one block in southwest Elmhurst that had seen 10 teardowns in six years, compared with one teardown and four expansions in 2006, and put the replacement homes there at about $1.5 million.
That shift from expansions to teardowns on one block shows how the math has changed. When land is worth enough, adding onto an existing house loses out to starting over. For a buyer, a block that has already turned over mostly to new construction prices every remaining older house with that possibility built in.
Teardown activity also matters to people who live here. In the city's housing survey, 229 respondents called for fewer teardowns. Among open-ended requests for housing changes, only more affordable housing came up more often. On January 26, 2026, the city's Development, Planning & Zoning Committee discussed a Historic Preservation Commission referral, demolition procedures and the possibility of a demolition-delay process. It asked staff for more information and continued the discussion to a future meeting, according to the DuPage Policy Journal.
The Illinois REALTORS DuPage County report for October 2026 shows a median sale price of $440,000 for all property types, up 6.4% from October 2025. Closed sales fell 5.5%, to 823, over the same comparison. Inventory reached 1,564 homes, up 17.4% from a year earlier, and homes averaged 21 days on market. Those are countywide figures. Across DuPage, buyers had more listings to choose from this October than last.
On the Elmhurst blocks near City Centre and the Prairie Path, a bigger county inventory does not remove the second set of bidders for an older house, the ones pricing the lot. The Zook cottage's February sale, at a per-square-foot price inside the range of this year's new builds, is what that competition looks like on a closing statement.
If you're comparing Elmhurst with other suburbs, first decide which group of buyers you belong to. If you plan to live in an older house and keep it, the blocks farther from the teardown clusters may give you more house for the money. If you want to walk downtown, expect to pay for the lot, and judge any older home there against what new construction is closing for nearby. Our Elmhurst neighborhood page and our earlier guide to buying near downtown Elmhurst cover the town more broadly.
Are older homes near downtown Elmhurst cheaper than new construction? The 1925 house at 231 S. Arlington sold for $507 per square foot in February 2026. New five-bedroom homes built in 2026 closed between $430 and $540 per square foot this year.
Where in Elmhurst are teardowns most common? The city's 2026 housing report says demolitions and new builds from 2020 through 2024 were most common near the Prairie Path and City Centre, with more activity north of North Avenue and near Butterfield Road.
What have new Elmhurst homes sold for in 2026? Shaw Local reported sales of homes built in 2026 at $1.6 million, $1.8 million and $2.53 million between July and October.
If you own an older home near downtown Elmhurst, a builder may value your lot very differently than a family buyer values your house. Before you set a price, we'll show you both numbers. Jeff/Amjad Salhani can walk you through recent Elmhurst sales of both new construction and preserved older homes. Let's connect and get your free home valuation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Preparation, Terms, and Timing Strategies That Help Hinsdale Buyers Stand Out.
What Draws Long-Term Buyers and Investors to Hinsdale's Historic Downtown, Train Access, and Established Neighborhoods.
What to Budget for Among the Costs of Buying a Home in Oak Brook IL.
A Guide to Investing in Real Estate in Burr Ridge IL.